December 11, 2006
You Just Can’t Say Such Things
Larry Summers learned the hard way that there are some things that you just don’t do in a university setting. Nancy Greene Raine, Chancellor of Thompson River University in Canada who also was a gold medalist skier in the 1960s, is learning the same lessons.
From the Kamloops Daily News last Saturday via a weblog:
University professors outraged by comments from TRU chancellor Nancy Greene Raine, who expressed doubt on climate change in a national media broadcast, met with her in a hastily called session Friday afternoon.
The meeting was arranged by senior administration at Thompson Rivers University following a cascade of e-mails among faculty concerned that her opinion reflects poorly on the university.
Penny Powers, a professor in the school of nursing confirmed earlier Friday she had been called to the meeting with Raine.
‘One of the most important goals of a university is to instill in the students an ability to assess the evidence for and against claims of any kind,’ she wrote in an e-mail to faculty.
‘What kind of role model do we put in place when the chancellor herself gives poorly-considered credence to widely discredited extremist opinions such as these?’ . . .
Charles Hays a professor of journalism at TRU, wrote in a message to colleagues that Greene Raine cannot be the symbolic head of the university and make statements that run counter to the overwhelming weight of scientific opinion.
‘And as chancellor, she has accepted a role as the symbolic head of the university. In that role, she owes it to the university not to make statements of opinion and expect that they will be perceived as merely the words of a private citizen.’
The Daily News was unable to reach anyone for comment on what took place during the meeting between faculty and Greene Raine.
What was it that the Chancellor said that set off this firestorm?
. . . another big name in Canadian skiing cautioned that people shouldn’t push the panic button.
“I am very suspicious now when I see people make blanket statements because there are two sides to every issue,” said Nancy Greene Raine, an Olympic gold medallist in the 1960s who has helped develop some of the top skiing resorts in British Columbia since her retirement.
“And in science there’s almost never black and white. We don’t know what next week’s weather going to be. To say in 50 or 100 years, the temperature is going to do this, is a bit of a stretch for me.”